next up previous
Next: Consequence of the Up: No Title Previous: No Title

A Working Hypothesis from the Correspondence Principle: .

The hypothesis which the Compton Scattering experiment most clearly highlights is the idea that individual photons from light of frequency should carry a momentum , where h is Planck's constant, . This hypothesis arises naturally as a consequence of the correspondence principle and the observation that, as a direct consequence of Maxwell's equations, a classical electromagnetic wave of energy U carries a momentum .

We can thus perform a thought-experiment where a monochromatic beam of light of frequency and energy U is directed at an absorbing plate. With our faith in Maxwell's equations, we know that after the plate absorbs the radiation, it will recoil in the experiment with a momentum given by . On the other hand, from the Planck Radiation formula and the photoelectric effect, we know that microscopically the energy of the beam arrived at the plate in a series of discrete packets or photons. To explain the recoil of the plate from this microscopic picture, it is natural to associate with each of the photons a momentum as well as an energy. To explain the magnitude of the observed recoil, the average momentum carried by the photons of must be the total recoil momentum divided by the number of photons, . Since all photons of frequency carry precisely the same energy, a further natural working hypothesis would be that they all carry the same momentum as well so that . Note that this cannot be concluded strictly from the though experiment, however, as we shall see this hypothesis is completely consistent with the experimental observations.



Prof. Tomas Alberto Arias
Wed Oct 11 20:18:35 EDT 1995