next up previous
Next: About this document Up: No Title Previous: Completing the correspondence

Discussion

Note that it is a quite natural consequence of the correspondence principle that precisely the same constant appears in both the momentum-wavelength and energy-frequency de Broglie relations (12). Although these relations related two different pairs of physical quantities, only one, and not two, fundamental constants are involved. Ultimately, the equality of these constants results from our definition of work as force times distance. If physicists had happened to decide to define work as one-half times the value of force times distance (so that we could write the kinetic energy of a particle as instead of ), then the two constants appearing in the de Broglie relations would be different, but by precisely the same factor of one-half.

It is also interesting to ponder the question of why the same value of Planck's constant should apply for photons as well as for every single kind of particle. This also comes about as a consequence of conservation laws. To link the value of Planck's constant for two different types of particles, we must consider a situation where two unlike particles interact as for example in the electron-photon collision in Compton Scattering. A full discussion of how to describe using waves a system containing more than one particle is beyond the scope of the course at this stage. We can, however, give a plausibility argument for the one fact which we need from a more advanced multiple particle description. To combine the energy of two particles (say when they are far enough apart that they are no longer interacting), we know that we simply add the energies of the two separate particles. As we have just seen, energy and frequency are related in direct proportion. So, it is plausible that when combining the waves describing these two particles the frequencies will add as well. Later we will see how this comes about. For now, if we accept this idea as plausible, we see that for energy and frequency both to be conserved simultaneously in all collisions exchanging energy/frequency between the two particles, the particles must share the same value for Planck's constant .



next up previous
Next: About this document Up: No Title Previous: Completing the correspondence



Prof. Tomas Alberto Arias
Wed Oct 11 18:33:11 EDT 1995