next up previous contents
Next: Renormalization Group and Summing Up: Three Nobel Ideas: Renormalization Previous: Three Nobel Ideas: Renormalization

Renormalization: Three scattering centers

 

Let us now consider scattering from a potential with three disturbances, such as the three tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -functions of strength D in Figure 17. The scattering amplitudes for a potential tex2html_wrap_inline2113 , as determined from solution of the TISE, are

  eqnarray640

where tex2html_wrap_inline2115 . Because the tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -function is symmetric, the scattering amplitudes are identical for both left- and right- incidence. Figure 17 shows four diagrams for transmission which illustrate the far richer variety of diagrams which we now face. Although there is a much richer variety, the number of these diagrams is still countable as they were in Figure 13. The meaning of the thick lines in the diagram will be explained presently.

   figure649
Figure 17: Transmission diagrams from a triple scatterer

Again, we seek a physical principle to organize the Feynman sum. The result will be a general form which is independent of the nature of the three scattering centers, and for which we may generate specific results by substituting in particular values for the quantum amplitudes.

The first two diagrams shown are part of an infinite subsequence of diagrams where the particle ricochets an arbitrary number of times between the first two barriers and then travels directly across to and though the third barrier. The sum of this subset of diagrams is

eqnarray658

where the tex2html_wrap_inline2119 factor we recognize as the complete Feynman sum for transmission across the first two barriers. The physical reason why we were able to factor this term out is that all processes which lead to transmission across the three barriers, no matter how complicated, begin with a sequence which carries the particle across the first two barriers. The sum of all of these beginning parts, tex2html_wrap_inline2119 , is clearly the sum of all ways in which we may cross the first two barriers and therefore must be the Feynman amplitude for transmission across the two first two barriers viewed as an isolated unit, hence the notation tex2html_wrap_inline2119 . All that we are doing is changing our view of the system and its fundamental processes. We are now beginning the consider the potential as consisting of two scatterers, the first being the first two tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -functions taken as a unit and the second being the third tex2html_wrap_inline1929 function.

In the third and fourth diagrams of Figure 17, the complete processes of all possible ways to transmit across the first two barriers as a unit is indicated by a very thick line. Such a notation is sometimes referred to as a dressed interaction in many-body physics. By using this notation, the diagrams in Figures 17.3 and 17.4 now serve to represent two different infinite subsets of diagrams. The total quantum amplitudes of these two subsets are given by the product of the labels in the diagram, tex2html_wrap_inline2129 and tex2html_wrap_inline2131 , respectively.

The idea of summing together an infinite subset of diagrams into a unit to produce a new fundamental process with its own quantum amplitude and diagram is known as renormalization. As we shall see, renormalization is a very powerful tool in organizing infinite sets of diagrams. This idea is used to deal with certain infinities which arise in quantum electrodynamics, the theory for which Feynman shared the Nobel prize with Schwinger and Tomonaga in 1965.

The the third and fourth diagrams in 17 begin another sequence of diagrams which we must consider. In this sequence, after somehow managing to penetrate through the first two tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -functions, the particle reflects once off of the third tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -function, then reflects from the unit consisting of the first two tex2html_wrap_inline1929 functions, after some number of ricochets, and then finally travels directly across to and though the third barrier. The sum of this infinite collection diagrams clearly involves tex2html_wrap_inline2139 , the amplitude for reflection from the right from the renormalized two tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -function unit. Algebraically, this part of the sum is

eqnarray666

We may now combine the renormalized left-transmission tex2html_wrap_inline2119 with our new renormalized right-reflection tex2html_wrap_inline2139 from the double tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -unit to describe all of the transmission diagrams for the triple tex2html_wrap_inline1937 -potential. So far, we have dealt with direct transmission tex2html_wrap_inline2151 and transmission after one ricochet between the third tex2html_wrap_inline1937 and our renormalized tex2html_wrap_inline1929 function pair, tex2html_wrap_inline2157 . The final diagram in Figure 17 gives the next set of terms in this renormalized sequence. In Figure 17.5 there are two ricochets between the renormalized double- tex2html_wrap_inline1937 unit and the isolated third tex2html_wrap_inline1937 function. Continuing in this way, now simply generated the general sequence of scattering between two barriers shown in Figure 15 but where where the nature of the two scatterers is different.

This completes the renormalization process. We now have a new, simpler set of Feynman rules for the problem at hand. The new set of rules now has a different set of fundamental processes, namely reflection and transmission across the first two tex2html_wrap_inline1929 functions as a renormalized unit, transmission and reflection from the third tex2html_wrap_inline1929 function, and propagation between them. The fact that the Feynman formulation is not specific about the form of the fundamental processes is what makes the renormalization process possible. Renormalization represents a change in what is considers to be the fundamental processes. The condition on what may be renormalized is that any history must be able to be sequenced unambiguously into the new fundamental processes. Grouping the first two tex2html_wrap_inline1929 functions together as a unit clearly satisfies this condition, because a scattering event from the third tex2html_wrap_inline1929 function can never be interleaved with the ricocheting between the first two tex2html_wrap_inline1929 functions. One could not, for instance, renormalize the outer two tex2html_wrap_inline1929 functions into a single unit, because then scattering processes within our ``fundamental process'' of scattering between the outer tex2html_wrap_inline1929 functions could be interrupted by scattering processes from the central tex2html_wrap_inline1929 function.

The final transmission amplitude across the three scatterers has now been reduced to a scattering problem between two scatterers, a renormalized unit made from the first two and the third ``bare'' scatterer. We may therefore use the result (21) with five substitutions. First, the propagation amplitude between the two barrier now becomes the transmission amplitude between the renormalized unit and the bare scatterer, tex2html_wrap_inline2179 . The transmission across the first barrier now becomes transmission across the renormalized unit, tex2html_wrap_inline2181 . Reflection off of the first barrier from the right now becomes reflection from the renormalized unit, tex2html_wrap_inline2183 . Finally, the reflection and transmission amplitudes from the second barrier become the reflection and transmission amplitudes from the isolated bare scatterer, tex2html_wrap_inline2185 and tex2html_wrap_inline2187 , respectively.

Alternately, we get precisely the same result by performing the Feynman sum corresponding to Figure 18,

  eqnarray674

As we have used no special properties of the amplitudes, this result is general. As we saw in Section 3.2, the transmission amplitudes in both directions are equal for any potential so that the amplitude for right-incident transmission is the same, tex2html_wrap_inline2189 .

   figure680
Figure 18: Complete set of renormalized transmission diagrams from a triple scatterer

Reflections from three general scatterers may be handled in the same way. We apply (22), where again tex2html_wrap_inline2179 , tex2html_wrap_inline2181 , tex2html_wrap_inline2183 , and tex2html_wrap_inline2185 , but now we need also reflection from the first barrier to become reflection from the renormalized unit tex2html_wrap_inline2199 and transmission from the right from the first unit to become transmission from the right through the renormalized unit, tex2html_wrap_inline2201 , where the equality follows from the discussion in Section 3.2.2. This gives,

  equation691

Again, one could obtain the same result by drawing and summing the appropriate renormalized Feynman diagrams.

Because the reflection amplitudes from the left and right need not be equal, to maintain generality we must give also the right-incident reflection amplitude tex2html_wrap_inline2203 . Again we use (22) where now tex2html_wrap_inline2179 , transmission across the first barrier into the scattering region is right- transmission through the bare scatterer tex2html_wrap_inline2207 , reflection from the second barrier is right-reflection from the renormalized unit tex2html_wrap_inline2209 , direct reflection from the first barrier is right-reflection from the bare unit tex2html_wrap_inline2211 , the ricochet reflections from the first barrier are left-reflection from the bare scatterer tex2html_wrap_inline2213 and final transmission through the first barrier is left-transmission through the bare unit tex2html_wrap_inline2215 . The final result is then

  equation697

Again, one could obtain the same result by drawing and summing the appropriate renormalized Feynman diagrams.

To complete the computation of the scattering amplitudes For the specific case of the three tex2html_wrap_inline1929 functions in Figure 17, we take tex2html_wrap_inline1623 and r=r' and t=t' from (25). In terms of these amplitudes, the specific values for tex2html_wrap_inline2119 and tex2html_wrap_inline2139 come directly from (21) and (22),

eqnarray706


next up previous contents
Next: Renormalization Group and Summing Up: Three Nobel Ideas: Renormalization Previous: Three Nobel Ideas: Renormalization

Prof. Tomas Alberto Arias
Thu May 29 15:16:11 EDT 1997